Shop AAPK Stores by:
AAPK on Facebook AAPK on Twitter

The Cattaraugus Company was started by John Champlin and his son Tint in 1882. It was first incorporated under the name J.B.F. Champlin and Son as a wholesale distribution company based in Little Valley, New York.  The business proved to be a successful endeavor, and it soon branched into a knife production company named Cattaraugus.

The knives that were created in these early years set the quality standard by which all other U.S. manufacturers were measured.

You will find some great examples of vintage old American cutlery history for sale here regularly.


Vintage CATTARAUGUS STAINLESS Model No. 2343 Equal End Oval Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 MOP

Vintage CATTARAUGUS STAINLESS Model No. 2343 Equal End Oval Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 MOP

1 In Stock

$64.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

 VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #32653 GENUINE PEARL SWELLCENTER WHITTLER KNIFE c1886/1963

VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #32653 GENUINE PEARL SWELLCENTER WHITTLER KNIFE c1886/1963

1 In Stock

$425.00


For Sale By:
jerdan

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model No. 42219C 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife Stag c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model No. 42219C 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife Stag c.1886-1963

1 In Stock

$255.00 $285.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. 42219 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife w/Compass Stag c1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. 42219 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife w/Compass Stag c1886-1963

1 In Stock

$295.00 $335.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Cattaraugus jack knife

Cattaraugus jack knife

1 In Stock

$100.00

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. 206 “SHRINE” Pen Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Enamel & Silver

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. 206 “SHRINE” Pen Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Enamel & Silver

1 In Stock

$84.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

 VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #32643 GENUINE PEARL SLEEVEBOARD WHITTLER KNIFE c1886/1963

VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #32643 GENUINE PEARL SLEEVEBOARD WHITTLER KNIFE c1886/1963

1 In Stock

$425.00


For Sale By:
jerdan

Vintage *RARE* CATTARAUGUS Equal End Shadow Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Tartan Celluloid 3 1/2”

Vintage *RARE* CATTARAUGUS Equal End Shadow Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Tartan Celluloid 3 1/2”

1 In Stock

$130.00 $148.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS 1-Blade Model #12099 Folding Hunter ‘DEER SLAYER” Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone

Vintage CATTARAUGUS 1-Blade Model #12099 Folding Hunter ‘DEER SLAYER” Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone

1 In Stock

$355.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model No. 21709 Barehead Slim Jack Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone Stag

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model No. 21709 Barehead Slim Jack Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone Stag

1 In Stock

$295.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS 1-Blade Model #12099- Folding Hunter ‘DEER SLAYER” Pocket Knife c.1906-1963 Bone

Vintage CATTARAUGUS 1-Blade Model #12099- Folding Hunter ‘DEER SLAYER” Pocket Knife c.1906-1963 Bone

1 In Stock

$375.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO 2-Blade Equal End Pen Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Jigged Bone

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO 2-Blade Equal End Pen Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Jigged Bone

1 In Stock

$115.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO MODEL No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO MODEL No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

1 In Stock

$265.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

1 In Stock

$165.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO 4-Blade Jr Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife JIGGED Bone c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO 4-Blade Jr Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife JIGGED Bone c.1886-1963

1 In Stock

$225.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Bone Stag1930’s-1950’s

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Bone Stag1930’s-1950’s

1 In Stock

$275.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

1 In Stock

$245.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag No Linerlock 1st Yr

Vintage CATTARAUGUS No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag No Linerlock 1st Yr

1 In Stock

$275.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model No. 42219C 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife Stag c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model No. 42219C 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket Knife Stag c.1886-1963

1 In Stock

$285.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 22823 Half Congress Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 22823 Half Congress Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

1 In Stock

$90.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY Model No. 2343 Equal End Oval Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 MOP

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY Model No. 2343 Equal End Oval Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 MOP

1 In Stock

$75.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS #4003 4-Blade Lobster Candle End Pocket Knife MOP c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS #4003 4-Blade Lobster Candle End Pocket Knife MOP c.1886-1963

1 In Stock

$110.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage Cattaraugus No. 32879 Sleeveboard Whittler Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone

Vintage Cattaraugus No. 32879 Sleeveboard Whittler Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone

1 In Stock

$172.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

 Vintage CATTARAUGUS #32794 Equal End Senator Whittler Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Yellow Celluloid

Vintage CATTARAUGUS #32794 Equal End Senator Whittler Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Yellow Celluloid

1 In Stock

$135.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage *RARE* CATTARAUGUS Equal End Shadow Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Tartan Celluloid 3 1/2”

Vintage *RARE* CATTARAUGUS Equal End Shadow Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Tartan Celluloid 3 1/2”

1 In Stock

$148.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

3 Pearl knives for repair Cattaraugus Whittler, New York Knife Co Whittler , Sword Brand  Camillus

3 Pearl knives for repair Cattaraugus Whittler, New York Knife Co Whittler , Sword Brand Camillus

1 In Stock

$70.00


For Sale By:
knifegnome

USED  VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #32183 GENUINE PEARL SERPENTINE CATTLE KNIFE c1886/1963

USED VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #32183 GENUINE PEARL SERPENTINE CATTLE KNIFE c1886/1963

1 In Stock

$115.00 $155.00


For Sale By:
jerdan

Vintage **RARE** CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO No. C2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

Vintage **RARE** CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO No. C2589 Whitt-L-Kraft Official Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

1 In Stock

$295.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley NY Pearl Mini Pen Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley NY Pearl Mini Pen Knife

1 In Stock

$100.00


For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus by A.G. Russell for the KCC Folding Hunter With Lock Seki Japan Made

Cattaraugus by A.G. Russell for the KCC Folding Hunter With Lock Seki Japan Made

1 In Stock

$141.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model 2014 Embossed Metal Shadow Pen Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS Model 2014 Embossed Metal Shadow Pen Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

1 In Stock

$74.50


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Cattaraugus Black Fixed Blade Knife

Cattaraugus Black Fixed Blade Knife

1 In Stock

$50.00


For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y.

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y.

1 In Stock

$275.00


For Sale By:
Joe's Resto's

Cattaraugus WW2  Model 250Q Commando Knfie

Cattaraugus WW2 Model 250Q Commando Knfie

1 In Stock

$125.00


For Sale By:
Knives Templar

Cattaraugus WW2 knife with Sheath Model 2250

Cattaraugus WW2 knife with Sheath Model 2250

1 In Stock

$200.00


For Sale By:
Arkansas Knives

Cattaraugus Campers Knife Bone Handles

Cattaraugus Campers Knife Bone Handles

1 In Stock

$195.00


For Sale By:
Knives Templar

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y.

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y.

Sold Out

$105.00


For Sale By:
Joe's Resto's

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 22609 Equal End Folding Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 22609 Equal End Folding Pen Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Bone

Sold Out

$100.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y.

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y.

Sold Out

$100.00


For Sale By:
Joe's Resto's

Cattaraugus CM-10 Bone Lockback Knife NIB

Cattaraugus CM-10 Bone Lockback Knife NIB

Sold Out

$100.00


For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Vintage Cattaraugus English jack

Vintage Cattaraugus English jack

Sold Out

$75.00


For Sale By:
Muskrat Man Knives

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 42219 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket KnifeBone

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 42219 4-Blade Camp/Utility Folding Pocket KnifeBone

Sold Out

$335.00


For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

A PAIR OF USED  VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO.  BONE PEN KNIVES c1886/1963

A PAIR OF USED VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. BONE PEN KNIVES c1886/1963

Sold Out

$125.00


For Sale By:
jerdan

Cattaraugus Cutlery (A.G. Russell) Large Toothpick Bolster Lock Seki Japan Made

Cattaraugus Cutlery (A.G. Russell) Large Toothpick Bolster Lock Seki Japan Made

Sold Out

$124.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

Never Used Cattaraugus Springdale, ARK Knife Serial #3085

Never Used Cattaraugus Springdale, ARK Knife Serial #3085

Sold Out

$85.00

Cattaraugus Scout/Utility Knife

Cattaraugus Scout/Utility Knife

Sold Out

$72.00


For Sale By:
Archway Cutlery

ANTIQUE/VINTAGE BONE CATTARAUGUS CUT CO LITTLE VALLEY #21479 JACK KNIFE/ SWEET to THE BONE

ANTIQUE/VINTAGE BONE CATTARAUGUS CUT CO LITTLE VALLEY #21479 JACK KNIFE/ SWEET to THE BONE

Sold Out

$149.49


For Sale By:
Sweetpieces4you

 VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #22153 GENUINE PEARL WARNCLIFFE 1/2 WHITTLER c1886/1963

VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #22153 GENUINE PEARL WARNCLIFFE 1/2 WHITTLER c1886/1963

Sold Out

$165.00


For Sale By:
jerdan

VINTAGE OLD CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. # 22919 BIG CIGAR JACK KNIFE 1886/1963

VINTAGE OLD CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. # 22919 BIG CIGAR JACK KNIFE 1886/1963

Sold Out

$295.00


For Sale By:
jerdan

Cattaraugus  Metal Handle Statue of Lady Liberty

Cattaraugus Metal Handle Statue of Lady Liberty

Sold Out

$30.00


For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

Cattaraugus by A.G. Russell Mediterranean Barlow Red Jigged Bone Seki Made Side Slide Lock

Cattaraugus by A.G. Russell Mediterranean Barlow Red Jigged Bone Seki Made Side Slide Lock

Sold Out

$97.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

Cattaraugus by A.G. Russell Seki Japan Made Tiny Toothpick

Cattaraugus by A.G. Russell Seki Japan Made Tiny Toothpick

Sold Out

$67.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

Rare Cattaraugus easy-open jack

Rare Cattaraugus easy-open jack

Sold Out

$51.00


For Sale By:
AGDO

Cattaraugus Cutlery KCC by A.G. Russell Bullet Lockback Brown Jigged Bone Handles 3 1/4” Closed OAL

Cattaraugus Cutlery KCC by A.G. Russell Bullet Lockback Brown Jigged Bone Handles 3 1/4” Closed OAL

Sold Out

$77.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. WRENCH KNIFE, Excellent Condition, Worm Grooved Bone Handles

CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. WRENCH KNIFE, Excellent Condition, Worm Grooved Bone Handles

Sold Out

$600.00


For Sale By:
Sweetwater Knives

CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. WRENCH or TOOL KNIFE, Excellent condition, Worm Grooved Bone Handles

CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. WRENCH or TOOL KNIFE, Excellent condition, Worm Grooved Bone Handles

Sold Out

$1,150.00


For Sale By:
Sweetwater Knives

Cattaraugus Pen Knife

Cattaraugus Pen Knife

Sold Out

$22.50


For Sale By:
Archway Cutlery

Cattaraugus (A.G.Russell)  Sleeveboard Whittler in Gorgeous Brown Jigged Bone Seki Made

Cattaraugus (A.G.Russell) Sleeveboard Whittler in Gorgeous Brown Jigged Bone Seki Made

Sold Out

$127.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

Cattaraugus (A.G.Russell) Toothpick in Brown Jigged Bone Made in Seki Japan

Cattaraugus (A.G.Russell) Toothpick in Brown Jigged Bone Made in Seki Japan

Sold Out

$27.50


For Sale By:
Sharpnshinyknives

Vintage Straight Razor-Cattaraugus Cut co. With Original Box

Vintage Straight Razor-Cattaraugus Cut co. With Original Box

Sold Out

$15.00

Showing 1 to 60 of 69 (2 Pages)