Cattaraugus Knives for Sale at AAPK

Sell On AAPK's Store Platform

Shop AAPK Stores by:

Cattaraugus

The Cattaraugus Company was started by John Champlin and his son Tint in 1882. It was first incorporated under the name J.B.F. Champlin and Son as a wholesale distribution company based in Little Valley, New York. The business proved to be a successful endeavor, and it soon branched into a knife production company named Cattaraugus.

The knives that were created in these early years set the quality standard by which all other U.S. manufacturers were measured.

You will find some great examples of vintage old American cutlery history for sale here regularly.

Vintage *RARE* CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model #22109F English Jack Worm Grooved Bone Stag 4 1/2” Long

Vintage RARE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model #22109F English Jack Worm Grooved Bone Stag 4 1/2” Long

This is an Uncommon and Hard to Find and Even RARE Antique or Vintage 4 1/2” Long Closed Lightly Used and Sharpened CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY Co. LITTLE VAL..

1 In Stock

Item # 35459

$195.00

For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 22489 Swell End Jack Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Jigged Bone

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 22489 Swell End Jack Pocket Knife c.1886-1963 Jigged Bone

If you don’t read the full description and look at all the photos you’re going to miss a lot of detail. Please ask questions if you still have any. T..

1 In Stock

Item # 35350

$125.00

For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY Model No. 22939 Balloon Half Whittler Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY Model No. 22939 Balloon Half Whittler Folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

If you don’t read the full description and look at all the photos you’re going to miss a lot of detail. Please ask questions if you still have any. T..

1 In Stock

Item # 35348

$82.50

For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 21479 Barehead Jack folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. 21479 Barehead Jack folding Pocket Knife c.1886-1963

If you don’t read the full description and look at all the photos you’re going to miss a lot of detail. Please ask questions if you still have any. T..

1 In Stock

Item # 35340

$135.00

For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Cattaraugus survival knife WW11

Cattaraugus survival knife WW11

Cattaraugus survival knife. with blade guard. excelant condition. blade is full. locks up tight. a little blade wobble when open. no cracks in handles..

1 In Stock

Item # 34667

$250.00

For Sale By:
knife-nut

Cattaraugus #2273 penknife

Cattaraugus #2273 penknife

BRAND: Cattaraugus PATTERN: Penknife #2273 LENGTH (Closed): 3” BOLSTERS: Nickel silver SHIELD: Bar shield HANDLES: According to C Houston..

1 In Stock

Item # 33781

$40.00

For Sale By:
Orvet Customs

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft "Official" Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

Vintage CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO Model No. D2589 Whitt-L-Kraft "Official" Boy Scout Pocket Knife Stag

If you don’t read the full description and look at all the photos you’re going to miss a lot of detail. Please ask questions if you still have any. T..

1 In Stock

Item # 33750

$235.00

For Sale By:
Robert’s Store

Vintage Cattaraugus Vanadium Kitchen Knife

Vintage Cattaraugus Vanadium Kitchen Knife

Hi, I have for sale a vintage Cattaraugus Kitchen knife. Has a black handle and is stamped "CATTARAUGUS VANADIUM" If you are missing a piece to your s..

1 In Stock

Item # 33717

$5.00

For Sale By:
Jaybedog Cutlery

Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY B52T Imitation Ivory Round Straight Razor

Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY B52T Imitation Ivory Round Straight Razor

Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY B52T Imitation Ivory Round Hollow Ground Straight Razor - Imitation Ivory Handles - No Cracks - Unuse..

1 In Stock

Item # 28897

$60.00

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus Red Bone Small Lock Back By A.G. Russell Model # CM-11

Cattaraugus Red Bone Small Lock Back By A.G. Russell Model # CM-11

A.G. Russell Cattaraugus Red Bone LockBack, Bob Cat Gold Etched on Blade Model # CM-11 . Never carried or sharpened . Made in Japan ,No Box . Red Bo..

1 In Stock

Item # 28688

$95.00

For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

Cattaraugus By A.G. Russell Model CM-10 Silver Bullet

Cattaraugus By A.G. Russell Model CM-10 Silver Bullet

Cattaraugus By A.G.Russell Red Bone Silver Bullet Serial #1007 on Back Spring . Model CM-10 . Can't tell if it has been carried or not because the bo..

1 In Stock

Item # 28613

$125.00

For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

RARE CATTARAUGUS KING OF WOODS EBONY

RARE CATTARAUGUS KING OF WOODS EBONY

CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. LITTLE VALLEY N.Y. (1886-1963)--COKE HUNTER LOCK, "KING OF WOODS TYPE"-5 3/8 INCHES CLOSED-CLIP BLADE STAINS & SCRATCHES SNAPS..

1 In Stock

Item # 24422

$295.00 $365.00

For Sale By:
My Historical Knives

Cattaraugus Springdale ARK K.C.C. CM-11 Japan Bone Bullet Lockback Knife in Box

Cattaraugus Springdale ARK K.C.C. CM-11 Japan Bone Bullet Lockback Knife in Box

Cattaraugus Springdale ARK K.C.C. (A.G. Russel - Knife Collectors Club) CM-11 Japan Bone Bullet Lockback Knife in Box - Serial # 1283 - Beautiful Jigg..

1 In Stock

Item # 23531

$74.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Rare Cattaraugus Little Valley NY Melon Tester #2219. 1900 Era

Rare Cattaraugus Little Valley NY Melon Tester #2219. 1900 Era

Rare Cattaraugus Little Valley NY Melon Tester type #2219. 1900 Era These don't come up for sale often in any condition. 4 1/2" Closed Dark Green Bon..

1 In Stock

Item # 22127

$500.00

For Sale By:
GHM Knives

SUPER OLD CATTARAUGUS ROGERS BONE SCOUT

SUPER OLD CATTARAUGUS ROGERS BONE SCOUT

CATTARAUGUS LITTLE VALLEY N.Y. (OLD)--#D-2589 SCOUT-4 BLADES 1 IS A LOCKING PUNCH-SUPER ROGERS BONE HANDLES WITH EAGLE BE PREPARED SHIELD. ..

Sold Out

Item # 35419

$175.00

For Sale By:
My Historical Knives

Vintage Cattaraugus 21819 Worm Groove Bone Barehead Jack Pocket Knife Knives

Vintage Cattaraugus 21819 Worm Groove Bone Barehead Jack Pocket Knife Knives

Excellent condition. No chips or cracks. Tight and snappy. ..

Sold Out

Item # 35286

$179.99

For Sale By:
dto1982

Cattaraugus Barlow #2159

Cattaraugus Barlow #2159

MAKER: Cattaraugus PATTERN: Barlow #2159 LENGTH (Closed): 3-1/4” BOLSTERS: Steel HANDLES: Bone BLADES: Clip & pen blades LINERS: Steel T..

Sold Out

Item # 30931

$40.00

For Sale By:
Orvet Customs

CATTARAUGUS JACK KNIFE, 2 Blades, Ebony Handles, Buffed but Nice, 1886 - 1963, Free Shipping

CATTARAUGUS JACK KNIFE, 2 Blades, Ebony Handles, Buffed but Nice, 1886 - 1963, Free Shipping

If you need more info on this or any of my listings, please email me with questions or for additional photos. sh74 TOTAL NUMBER OF KNIV..

Sold Out

Item # 25086

$99.95

For Sale By:
Sweetwater Knives

Cattaraugus Springdale ARK K.C.C. CM-10 Japan 20th Century Barlow Bone Bullet Lockback Knife in Box

Cattaraugus Springdale ARK K.C.C. CM-10 Japan 20th Century Barlow Bone Bullet Lockback Knife in Box

Cattaraugus Springdale ARK K.C.C. (A.G. Russel - Knife Collectors Club) CM-10 Japan "20th Century Barlow" Bone Bullet Lockback Knife in Box - Serial #..

Sold Out

Item # 23530

$124.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus Bone Handle Lock-back Pattern CM-11E A.G. Russell

Cattaraugus Bone Handle Lock-back Pattern CM-11E A.G. Russell

A.G. Russell Cattaraugus Made in Japan . Never carried or sharpened . No wobble new in Box Nice Red Bone Handles with no chips or cracks . Nickle Silv..

Sold Out

Item # 23276

$55.00

For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY Bone Model 22059 Small Congress Knife c.1886-1963

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY Bone Model 22059 Small Congress Knife c.1886-1963

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY Bone Model 22059 Small Congress Knife c.1886-1963 - Beautiful Genuine Bone Handles - No Cracks - Nickel Silve..

Sold Out

Item # 21465

$84.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley

Bone Handle Cattaraugus Little Valley Nice old Knie Has been used and toted . Looks like a pin crack at front pin hard to see. other wise great looki..

Sold Out

Item # 20575

$65.00

For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

Cattaraugus 35th Anniversary A.G.Russell Knife Collector Club Ivory

Cattaraugus 35th Anniversary A.G.Russell Knife Collector Club Ivory

Cattaraugus Mommouth Ivory . For A. G. Russell Collector Club in 2005 . Never carried or sharpened. Real tight knife to open and close does have a l..

Sold Out

Item # 20548

$255.00

For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

Cattaraugus Bone Handle Front Lock Toothpick A.G. Russell

Cattaraugus Bone Handle Front Lock Toothpick A.G. Russell

Cattaraugus Bone handle Toothpick Silver Bullett inlay in handle . Made in Japan by A.G. Russell . Model CM-12 .never carried or sharpened . has front..

Sold Out

Item # 19782

$55.00

For Sale By:
Kennedy Knives

Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout Pocket Knife In Excellent Condition With Brown Jigged Bone Covers (723)

Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout Pocket Knife In Excellent Condition With Brown Jigged Bone Covers (723)

We are pleased to offer this Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout pocket knife in Excellent Condition. This 4-Blade 3 5/8" long pocket knife has wonderful Br..

Sold Out

Item # 19747

$175.00

For Sale By:
Cosgrove Cutlery

Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout Pocket Knife In Excellent Condition With Black Jigged Bone Covers (724)

Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout Pocket Knife In Excellent Condition With Black Jigged Bone Covers (724)

We are pleased to offer this Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout pocket knife in Excellent Condition. This 4-Blade 3 3/4" long pocket knife has wonderful Bl..

Sold Out

Item # 19748

$150.00

For Sale By:
Cosgrove Cutlery

Cattaraugus In Very Good Condition With Brown Jigged Bone Covers 3 5/16

Cattaraugus In Very Good Condition With Brown Jigged Bone Covers 3 5/16" Long (632)

We are pleased to offer this Cattaraugus Vintage pocket knife in Very Good Condition. This 2-Blade 3 5/16" long pocket knife has wonderful Brown Jigg..

Sold Out

Item # 19322

$50.00

For Sale By:
Cosgrove Cutlery

Cattaraugus In Excellent Condition With Brown Jigged Bone Covers 3 5/8" Long (513)

Cattaraugus In Excellent Condition With Brown Jigged Bone Covers 3 5/8" Long (513)

We are pleased to offer this Cattaraugus Unofficial Scout pocket knife in Excellent Condition. This 4-Blade 3 5/8" long pocket knife has wonderful Br..

Sold Out

Item # 19229

$50.00

For Sale By:
Cosgrove Cutlery

Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY B52T Imitation Ivory Round Straight Razor in Box

Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY B52T Imitation Ivory Round Straight Razor in Box

Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY B52T Imitation Ivory Round Hollow Ground Straight Razor in Box - Imitation Ivory Handles - No Cracks ..

Sold Out

Item # 18741

$59.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Custom Reproduction sheath for Cattaraugus 225Q

Custom Reproduction sheath for Cattaraugus 225Q

Custom handmade sheath for Cattaraugus 225Q WWII era combat knife . Made from vegetable tanned 6-7 oz premium cowhide, smooth side out. Patterned off ..

Sold Out

Item # 18148

$35.00

For Sale By:
Muskrat Man Knives

Cattaraugus Pen Knife

Cattaraugus Pen Knife

MAKER: Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. PATTERN: 2282 O LENGTH (Closed): 2-5/16 BOLSTERS: Nickel silver HANDLES: Opal Pearl BLADES: Pin..

Sold Out

Item # 17776

$60.00

For Sale By:
Orvet Customs

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Model 1139 Genuine Saw Cut Bone 1 Blade Barlow Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Model 1139 Genuine Saw Cut Bone 1 Blade Barlow Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Model 1139 Genuine Saw Cut Bone 1 Blade Barlow Knife - Genuine Saw Cut Bone Handles - No Cracks - Iron Bolsters - Iron Liners ..

Sold Out

Item # 16320

$149.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus Cigar Whittler

Cattaraugus Cigar Whittler

MAKER: Cattaraugus PATTERN: Cigar whittler LENGTH (Closed): 3-1/2” BOLSTERS: Steel SHIELD: Nickel silver HANDLES: Cattaraugus’..

Sold Out

Item # 15715

$85.00

For Sale By:
Orvet Customs

Cattaraugus Barlow 2159 with saw cut bone handles

Cattaraugus Barlow 2159 with saw cut bone handles

This is a nice Barlow from Cattaraugus.Pattern number 2159. Has been used, carried and sharpened.Clip point master blade. Master blade has good snap a..

Sold Out

Item # 15278

$100.00

For Sale By:
Goldpan's Knives

Cattaraugus Barlow 2139 with saw cut bone handles #2

Cattaraugus Barlow 2139 with saw cut bone handles #2

This is a nice Barlow from Cattaraugus.Pattern number 2139. Has been used, carried and sharpened.Spear point master blade. Master blade has good snap ..

Sold Out

Item # 15277

$100.00

For Sale By:
Goldpan's Knives

Cattaraugus Barlow 2139 with saw cut bone handles

Cattaraugus Barlow 2139 with saw cut bone handles

This is a nice Barlow from Cattaraugus.Pattern number 2139. C.C.C. is stamped on the bolster. Has been used, carried and sharpened.Spear point master ..

Sold Out

Item # 15276

$90.00

For Sale By:
Goldpan's Knives

Cattaraugus Barlow 1159 with smooth bone handles

Cattaraugus Barlow 1159 with smooth bone handles

This is a nice Barlow from Cattaraugus.Pattern number 1159. Cattaraugus is stamped on the bolster. Clip point master blade. Master blade has good snap..

Sold Out

Item # 15259

$30.00

For Sale By:
Goldpan's Knives

Old Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Knife with Original Stamped Sheath

Old Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Knife with Original Stamped Sheath

8 1/2" overall knife. The blade is full, a few light scratches at 4 1/2". The guard stamped "Cattaraugus". Handles are stacked leather spacers, all ti..

Sold Out

Item # 14782

$65.00

For Sale By:
Nutmeg State Knives

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Model 2159 Genuine Saw Cut Bone 2 Blade Barlow Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Model 2159 Genuine Saw Cut Bone 2 Blade Barlow Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Model 2159 Genuine Saw Cut Bone 2 Blade Barlow Knife - Genuine Saw Cut Bone Handles - No Cracks - Iron Bolsters - Iron Liners ..

Sold Out

Item # 13140

$125.00

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY Bone 2 Blade Barlow Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY Bone 2 Blade Barlow Knife

Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Little Valley NY Bone 2 Blade Barlow Knife - Genuine Bone Handles - No Cracks - Iron Bolsters - Iron Liners - Snaps Open and S..

Sold Out

Item # 8776

$100.00

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

C.C.C. Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Bone 2159 Barlow Knife

C.C.C. Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Bone 2159 Barlow Knife

C.C.C. Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Bone 2159 Barlow Knife - Saw Cut Bone Handles - No Cracks - Iron Bolsters - Iron Liners - Snaps Open and Shut - No Wobb..

Sold Out

Item # 6578

$69.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus K.C.C. CM-17 Japan (A.G. Russel) Bone Locking Blade Knife

Cattaraugus K.C.C. CM-17 Japan (A.G. Russel) Bone Locking Blade Knife

Cattaraugus K.C.C. CM-17 Japan (A.G. Russel) Bone Locking Blade Knife - Bone Handles - No Cracks - Engraved Nickel Silver Bolsters - Nickel Silver Lin..

Sold Out

Item # 8188

$149.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Cattaraugus USA-1 (A.G. Russel) Brass Statue of Liberty 2 Blade Pen Knife - NIB

Cattaraugus USA-1 (A.G. Russel) Brass Statue of Liberty 2 Blade Pen Knife - NIB

Cattaraugus USA-1 (A.G. Russel) Brass Statue of Liberty 2 Blade Pen Knife - NIB - Engraved Brass Handles - Snaps Open and Shut - No Wobble - Near to M..

Sold Out

Item # 2685

$29.95

For Sale By:
Sanders Knives

Showing 1 to 43 of 43 (1 Pages)