Mystery Knife Game

[TwoFlowersLuggage]

Saw a question as to multiple guesses. I did so and apologize if that was outside the boundaries.

I don't know what the rules are for sure.But don't fret it,just 1 guess per post until we know different.

FYI - I think what was said earlier in the thread was one guess per day, per knife. So, if no one has gotten it by the next day, you can make another guess. If someone does get it and posts another knife, then you can make another guess on the new game.

I'm not the referee - I'm just echoing what I understood the rules to be. But, hey, this is like "Calvinball" (from the Calvin & Hobbs comic) - make it up as ya go!

[richard]

Union Cutlery Company, now ka-bar ?

[edge213]

Saw a question as to multiple guesses. I did so and apologize if that was outside the boundaries.

I don't know what the rules are for sure.But don't fret it,just 1 guess per post until we know different.

FYI - I think what was said earlier in the thread was one guess per day, per knife. So, if no one has gotten it by the next day, you can make another guess. If someone does get it and posts another knife, then you can make another guess on the new game.

I'm not the referee - I'm just echoing what I understood the rules to be. But, hey, this is like "Calvinball" (from the Calvin & Hobbs comic) - make it up as ya go!

calvinball-only-permanent-rule.jpg

I may be mistaken, but I don't believe glennbad stated any rules when he started this game.
It was suggested later by another to limit guesses.
I'm sure he meant this to be fun, so I say make as many guesses as you want.

[kennedy knives]

Union Cutlery Company, now ka-bar ?

No

[kennedy knives]

Northfield knife

Winner Winner now it's your turn thanks to all
A little History with this
Northfield from 1858 to 1919
Clark Bros from 1919 to 1931
Henry Gill used it in 1964
Parker 1993 to when ever GEC has it now

[glennbad]

I don't know what the rules are for sure.But don't fret it,just 1 guess per post until we know different.

FYI - I think what was said earlier in the thread was one guess per day, per knife. So, if no one has gotten it by the next day, you can make another guess. If someone does get it and posts another knife, then you can make another guess on the new game.

I'm not the referee - I'm just echoing what I understood the rules to be. But, hey, this is like "Calvinball" (from the Calvin & Hobbs comic) - make it up as ya go!

calvinball-only-permanent-rule.jpg

I may be mistaken, but I don't believe glennbad stated any rules when he started this game.
It was suggested later by another to limit guesses.
I'm sure he meant this to be fun, so I say make as many guesses as you want.

I don't see anything wrong with making multiple guesses, as long as you wait for the poster to shoot down your guess before making another guess. (which everyone is already doing!)

Glad to see everyone is having fun with this!

[kennedy knives]

Saw a question as to multiple guesses. I did so and apologize if that was outside the boundaries.

I don't know what the rules are for sure.But don't fret it,just 1 guess per post until we know different.

FYI - I think what was said earlier in the thread was one guess per day, per knife. So, if no one has gotten it by the next day, you can make another guess. If someone does get it and posts another knife, then you can make another guess on the new game.

I'm not the referee - I'm just echoing what I understood the rules to be. But, hey, this is like "Calvinball" (from the Calvin & Hobbs comic) - make it up as ya go!

calvinball-only-permanent-rule.jpg

Glad I have no dog in this fight
Fun game I will say you get to learn a little as the game go's on
Keeps you busy

[knifegnome]

Your next Mystery knife is ...

[edge213]

Robeson

[knifegnome]

No,not Robeson ,but I thought for sure it was when I first saw it in a case at the flea market.

[1967redrider]

Cattaraugus?

[New_Windsor_NY]

Your next Mystery knife is ...

Utica Cutlery Company.

[knifegnome]

Not Cattaraugus or Utica.

[glennbad]

Crucible

[philco]

Wards ?

[knifegnome]

Not Crucible or Wards
Hint: A New England Co.

[LongBlade]

H&B

[richard]

Ulster?

[Mumbleypeg]

Thomaston

Ken

[knifegnome]

But not in Conn.

[Mumbleypeg]

But not in Conn.

That eliminates most of my other New England guesses! But it does narrow things down a good bit.

Ken

[knife7knut]

Burkinshaw?

[WillyCamaro]

Oh boy, are we not going waaaaay out there, into lost brand land.

[knifegnome]

Yes ,Aaron Burkinshaw
dates
A. Burkinshaw ,Buryville 1853-1856
A. Burkinshaw ,Pepperell 1856-1881
A. Burkinshaw's Sons 1881-1920
Burkinshaw Knife Co 1881-1920
Two trademarks they used were "PAIN" and "EXILE"

Good job Knife7knut, your up!

[richard]

But not in Conn.

buryville is in conn?