Quiz time again

Kiferbros · Post by **Kiferbros** » Tue Dec 12, 2006 2:12 am

what do you think and why???

http://cgi.ebay.com/RARE-ANTIQUE-HOLLIN ... dZViewItem

jonet143 · Post by **jonet143** » Tue Dec 12, 2006 3:09 am

the tang stamps look real to me. they look like the examples i have. the handles don't seem right though. but the backsprings seem to fit the blades as far as age. but i know very little about the company or knives they made.

Ratchet · Post by **Ratchet** » Tue Dec 12, 2006 4:30 am

Looks real to me..., I like the look of it.

Ratchet

PA Knives · Post by **PA Knives** » Tue Dec 12, 2006 3:08 pm

I have to jump in here, I will reserve my thoughts on the first posting until later. But I thought that if you look at this other listing it might help with additional conversation and learning by the troops here.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... :IT&ih=014

Compare and discuss each of them. ::blah:: ::blah:: ::blah::

I know the answer, DO YOU?

Great chance to learn here folks, thanks Kiferbros for a great post,

Keep up the good work,

stockman · Post by **stockman** » Tue Dec 12, 2006 5:26 pm

Hello Kniferbros and PA I looked these two knives over. The first one has enough pictures to try to make a judgement on, the second knife not enough information for me. On the second knife there is no detail to pictures to tell much, the first knife the pictures are not much better but you can see some detail of the blade profile and the frame and handles. The handles look to me to be deteriorating, possibably even gassing. It is my guess that the first knife is real,the second I don't know. Hope I don't look stupid!!

Stockman

muskrat man · Post by **muskrat man** » Tue Dec 12, 2006 6:30 pm

the first knife dosen't look right to me, springs just don't sit right with me, just my .02

knifeaholic · Post by **knifeaholic** » Wed Dec 13, 2006 2:09 am

The first one looks real, but the main blade tang stamp looks like it might be an overstamped "second" similar to the knives that are marked EAGLE PHILA.

Second one not enough detail....frame and handles look like Winchester/Walden/Keen Kutter. But would anyone fake a knife with the main blade broken and reshaped like that?

Little Rock · Post by **Little Rock** » Wed Dec 13, 2006 5:23 pm

Looks like the small blade tang has been filed off round. Not being an expert would make me wonder about the small blade.

PA Knives · Post by **PA Knives** » Thu Dec 14, 2006 1:09 pm

Folks,

I am on my way to Orlando to judge dogs, but I wanted to leave this message before I go.

I would have purchased either of these knives with confidence. Both in my opinion are the real thing. If you disagree and you are welcome to do so, PLease tell me why you think I am wrong.

I don't mind be corrected and learning,

That's why we are here.

Have a great weekend.

Kiferbros · Post by **Kiferbros** » Thu Dec 14, 2006 2:16 pm

I liked the first one top to bottom, a nice old one that has been unmolested but in need of some TLC. the only flaw on this one is age, sometimes a truly old knife that has been unmolested in either good or rough shape can give the impression of having been messed with, but the signs are there if you look hard enough.

The second posted by PA ...well I would have my concerns as it is shown. I would want to see better photos of the knife and some shots of the stampings but the frame, handles and blade combination look ok. but going off of what I seen I would have concerns...in this case I would e-mail seller and ask for more photos and what the photos should be of then a good decision could be make. you can never have too much information to base a decision on and it can mean the difference on missing out on a real nice piece at a good price.

Great work everyone