Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
-
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2018 8:49 pm
Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
Comparing them at their respective best, what would be the ranking order of these brands in terms of overall quality?
- Eye Brand Man
- Posts: 504
- Joined: Fri Nov 07, 2014 6:34 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
That's a very subjective question. A lot will have to do with time period a given knife was produced. Ulster and Utica made some fine knives from the 20's thru the 40's. But i'd list them pretty much as your title. Ulster,Utica,Imperial, Colonial. YMMV.
Eye Brand Collector
-
- Posts: 2950
- Joined: Fri Feb 28, 2014 5:25 pm
- Location: Lower Hudson River valley, N.Y.
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
Ulster before WW2 was head and shoulders above the other three you list. At least a head above Case too if hand made quality is what counts. Utica did make some nicer knives early on in their history but Ulster was a true premium brand.
- tongueriver
- Posts: 7098
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 8:01 pm
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
Oh yeah... Love them old Ulsters.
- TripleF
- Silver Tier
- Posts: 19257
- Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2011 3:42 pm
- Location: West Central FL
- Contact:
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
Well, you asked.....the Imperial USA (not Ireland) carbon steel is hands down my top to sharpen and put a wicked edge on it.
Id take an Imperial over the other 3 any day of the week!!!
Id take an Imperial over the other 3 any day of the week!!!
SCOTT
HOME OF THE BRAVE! (not the scarety cats)
https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/catalog/triplef
Colonial Knife Company History ebook:
https://gumroad.com/l/ZLDb
HOME OF THE BRAVE! (not the scarety cats)
https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/catalog/triplef
Colonial Knife Company History ebook:
https://gumroad.com/l/ZLDb
- edge213
- Gold Tier
- Posts: 8171
- Joined: Sat Jan 25, 2014 12:48 am
- Location: The Crossroads of America
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
You have them in the order that I would put them in.
David
"Glowing like the metal on the edge of a knife" Meat Loaf
"Glowing like the metal on the edge of a knife" Meat Loaf
-
- Posts: 10462
- Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 9:02 pm
- Location: Tecumseh,Michigan
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
The solid bolster Imperials of the 1930's are at least the quality of the Ulster & Utica knives.The early Colonial knives are just as good as well.I would say you could arrange them in any order and you would be right.JMHO
EDIT: Here are examples of all 4 brands;you pick the one you like the best.
EDIT: Here are examples of all 4 brands;you pick the one you like the best.
Adventure BEFORE Dementia!
- orvet
- Gold Tier
- Posts: 19574
- Joined: Tue May 16, 2006 6:23 am
- Location: Willamette Valley, Oregon
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
I agree with Eye Brand Man it depends on what time periods your speaking of.
If you're talking in the 1920s up to mid-1930s Ulster, Utica and Imperial all made well-built, solid knives, though I might give a slight edge to Ulster. Imperial started making shell handle knives in the late 1930s, while they did use quality steel knives, I would not say that shell handle knives compared to the quality of the earlier solid bolster Imperial's.
I don't know much about the early Colonials, but the later stuff I've seen made after World War II was not as good as the others, IMHO. I personally thought the shell handle Imperial's of the 1950s and 60s were better than the Colonials made in the same period.

If you're talking in the 1920s up to mid-1930s Ulster, Utica and Imperial all made well-built, solid knives, though I might give a slight edge to Ulster. Imperial started making shell handle knives in the late 1930s, while they did use quality steel knives, I would not say that shell handle knives compared to the quality of the earlier solid bolster Imperial's.
I don't know much about the early Colonials, but the later stuff I've seen made after World War II was not as good as the others, IMHO. I personally thought the shell handle Imperial's of the 1950s and 60s were better than the Colonials made in the same period.
Dale
AAPK Administrator
Please visit my AAPK store: www.allaboutpocketknives.com/orvet
Job 13:15
"Buy more ammo!" - Johnnie Fain
“Evil is Powerless If The Good are Unafraid.” – Ronald Reagan
AAPK Administrator
Please visit my AAPK store: www.allaboutpocketknives.com/orvet
Job 13:15
"Buy more ammo!" - Johnnie Fain
“Evil is Powerless If The Good are Unafraid.” – Ronald Reagan
-
- Posts: 2950
- Joined: Fri Feb 28, 2014 5:25 pm
- Location: Lower Hudson River valley, N.Y.
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
Even in the early days of their companies neither Utica, Imperial, or Colonial made knives of the quality of Ulster. They did not have the beautiful grinds or "swedges" of the Ulsters. One will not find many premium scales on the others either, ever seen a stag Colonial or Imperial? Utica? Pearl? The Ulsters when new had many gorgeous blade etches, and all their knives were stronger made than the others. When other companies had gone to automatic grinding machines and other modernization of their plants the owner of Ulster refused to modernize and all their blades were hand ground into the WW2 era even though the company lost money for twenty years or so. Ulster after the war are no better than the imperials because Ulster was bought up by Schrade-Imperial and had all the knives made on automated machines. I think that anybody who disagrees has never actually held a near mint 1880-1930 Ulster in their hands, they were among the best ever made.
- btrwtr
- Gold Tier
- Posts: 5212
- Joined: Thu May 24, 2012 11:53 am
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
I agree with the order; Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial. Opinion is that although I have had some Imperials and Utca knives that were fine overall quality of the early production Ulster knives was tops.
If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of giants.
Wayne
Please visit My AAPK store https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/catalog/btrwtr
Wayne
Please visit My AAPK store https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/catalog/btrwtr
- WillyCamaro
- Posts: 6121
- Joined: Thu Jan 10, 2019 4:03 am
- Location: Yorkton, Saskatchewan
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
I think that a very fair assessment
. I personally feel all of them are great knives. Can't beat Imperials for sharpening though.

"Never, never, never give up."
Winston Churchill
"He has given you the spirit of repentance, a soul that longs for redemption.
He is quick to forgive, and kind in His mercy toward you, a lowly sinner."
Winston Churchill
"He has given you the spirit of repentance, a soul that longs for redemption.
He is quick to forgive, and kind in His mercy toward you, a lowly sinner."
-
- Gold Tier
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Mon Jan 18, 2016 5:15 pm
Re: Ulster, Utica, Imperial, Colonial...
I like Imperials, but not shell handles.
Gary
"Now it cuts like a knife, but it feels so right." Bryan Adams
"Now it cuts like a knife, but it feels so right." Bryan Adams