$190.00 
$199.95 
$249.95 
$150.00 
$220.00 
$175.00 
$152.00 
$134.50 
$95.00 
$68.00 
$510.00 
$35.00 
$34.95 
$25.00 
$27.50 
$72.95 
Shop AAPK Stores by:
Recent Conversation Topics
- Albers Stag
- Covid test
- Dabora???
- Jos. Rodgers Ivory 'Tea' Cutlery
- Stag heavy duty ULU SOLD
- Buy local, pay more?
- Help with identifying a knife
- Old cattaraugus Harness jack
- Happy Birthday Cutmyself..
- Carl Schlieper
- Is my SOG experience 'normal'?
- Marital Problems? This knife may be just what you need ;-)
- BD1N Steel
- ID of old Western folder
- Case Classic 1993 Really Worth $500?
Case XX 5172, P172 Bulldog knife price guide
Be sure to check out the W.R. Case pocket knives up for sale in the AAPK member store when you get finished with the knife value guides!
| Year | Pattern Number | Handle Description | Other Discerning Features | Estimated Market Value |
| 1940 - 1964 | 5172 | genuine stag | with box | $450.01 |
| 1965 - 1969 | 5172 | genuine stag | bulldog etch w/ box | $427.00 |
| 1965 - 1969 | P172 | wood | buffalo etch - with box | $176.25 |
| 1972 | P172 | wood | with box | $101.00 |
| 1973 | P172 | wood | with box | $100.00 |
| 1974 | P172 | wood | buffalo etch with box | $127.00 |
| 1976 | 5172 SSP | genuine stag | hand made USA stamp | $174.00 |
| 1976 | P172 | wood | buffalo etch w/ box | $124.69 |
| 1977 | 5172 SSP | genuine stag | blue scroll | $167.00 |
| 1977 | P172 | pakkawood | no | $67.50 |
| 1979 | P172 | pakkawood | hand made usa | $103.00 |
| 1980 | P172 SSP | wood | boss etch with box | $140.02 |
| 1981 | P172 L SSP | wood | boss etch with box | $82.00 |
| Browse by pattern: | ||
Have Case or Case Classic pocket Knives for sale? AAPK offers exciting selling oportunities!
If you are a regular seller of knives, you definitely need to check out our knife specific retail platform. It is an extraordinary venue for buying & selling knives. Inventory turnover is great & the commission rate is incredibly low. Visit our getting started selling page to learn more!
If you are not a knife retailer and just have a few knives, or a collection of knives you want to sell; many of our members buy knives & knife collections of all sizes. If you would like to get offers, contact us & tell us what you've got. We'll pass your info on to the many buyers who may be interested.