Page 2 of 2

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2011 9:45 pm
by FRJ
Wow, a bunch of really impressive knives.

elbertson, my favorite of your favorites is the Ontario Parachutist USMC-94.
Thanks for showing them guys.

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2011 10:04 pm
by elbertson
Thanks,I'd really like to use that Ontario,too. If I had another, I surely would!

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Thu Jul 21, 2011 3:06 am
by Owd Wullie
Elbertson,

You'd have LOVED my stash of old mil surp stuff that I sold off in the late 90's.

Most of it came from Bannerman's Island Arsenal if that gives you any idea.

The one I regret selling the most now was a "forager's knife" made at Watervliet Arsenal. Looked a lot like the Hospital Corps knife, but the sheath was different. Had a trowel bayonet too.

Oh well.

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Sun Aug 07, 2011 8:18 pm
by philco
Thanks for showing us your great collection Elbertson. I don't collect fixed blade knives. I have chosen instead to focus like a lazer beam on my slipjoint collection. :roll: Oh, now and then a fixed blade knife will come along and follow me back to my house, but really, I don't collect them......

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Sun Aug 07, 2011 8:41 pm
by philco
A few more...............

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Sun Aug 07, 2011 8:48 pm
by philco
Just a few more..........

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Sun Aug 07, 2011 9:20 pm
by rangerbluedog
philco wrote:Thanks for showing us your great collection Elbertson. I don't collect fixed blade knives. I have chosen instead to focus like a lazer beam on my slipjoint collection. :roll: Oh, now and then a fixed blade knife will come along and follow me back to my house, but really, I don't collect them......
Wow, it's a good thing you don't collect them - otherwise you might need a bigger house!
Those collection of Bucks are nice. That Bark River and Savage made sheath in the last picture REALLY got my attention! Is the sheath custom or did it come with the knife? (it looks like a horizontal rig...)

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Sun Aug 07, 2011 9:31 pm
by philco
Blue that Savage made sheath for the Bark River knife was a recent ebay buy for me. My Barkie came with a kydex sheath that I found not to my liking, so after a wait of over a year I broke down and purchased the leather one from Savage. It is set up for vertical carry.

Phil

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Sun Aug 07, 2011 9:35 pm
by rangerbluedog
That is quite an improvement! I'm not a fan of kydex - nothing like leather for a good sheath or holster. ::tu::
I just visited his webpage http://www.savagemadesheaths.com/
The man is an artist...

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 3:28 pm
by jerryd6818
I fell in love with the Kabar/fighting knife/combat knife/MK-2 or whatever else you want to call it, while I was in the service. I'm sure I've told the story about buying my first Kabar while stationed at 29 Palms, CA from a guy that worked in supply and then getting it stolen from my wall locker. I finally got one to keep (Camillius) from a local Army/Navy Store back sometime in the late '70s or early 80's. Take a look and let me know if you think it was an issue knife. (not one that was issued but one that was made to be issued) It was brand new when I bought it with a raw untouched handle. I "aged" the handle so it would look like the ones the Sergeants and Staff NCOs carried.

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 3:33 pm
by jerryd6818
I picked up a couple of KA-BARs sometime around 2000.
KA-Bar 1217 USMC Combat Knife & Sheath.JPG
KA-BAR 02-1242 USMC Combat Viet Nam Memorial Commerative Knife & Sheath Front.JPG
KA-BAR 02-1242 USMC Combat Viet Nam Memorial Commerative Blade Etch.JPG
And one of the short models.
KA-BAR 02-1250 Short USMC Combat Knife & Sheath.JPG

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 3:39 pm
by jerryd6818
Also a Case
Case USMC Marine Knife & Sheath.JPG
Case USMC Marine Knife Tang Stamp.JPG
Case USMC Marine Knife Tang Stamp 2.JPG

And an Ontario
Ontario P4 USMC Combat Knife & Sheath.JPG
Ontario P4 USMC Combat.JPG
Ontario P4 USMC Combat 2.JPG

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 4:04 pm
by philco
Jerry,

How would you compare the overall quallity of the Case, Ka-Bar, and Ontario knives you have shown ?

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 8:04 pm
by elbertson
Phil - those knives of yours are nice! I really like the blade shape on that Bravo

Jerry - My guess on your Camillus is that it wasn't made for issue, mainly based on the handle not being coated with that Ox-blood brown or black coating, which would be spec. Other than that, I'm pretty sure there wouldn't be anything else about it that I can see that would be different than the issue ones. Markings would put it at 1974 or after.

Is your Ontario 440A?

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 8:21 pm
by jerryd6818
Phil, I'm assuming you're talking about "quality = fit & finish" and not the quality of the steel or usefulness of the knife.

I think it's a tie between the Ontario and the KA-BARs. I don't know what that finish is on the blades of the KA-BARs, whether it's powder coat or paint. It pretties up the blade but I'm not especially fond of it. Ontario failed to clean that little bit of gunk out of the fuller. Though it may get the goat of others, that's not a real big deal to me. For production knives, I think they're both pretty well put together and I can't really pick one over the other.

I'm guessing leather is difficult to turn on a lathe but both the other knives are well done, the Case isn't. I'm sure it's a sturdy knife and I don't have a problem with a parkerized blade (I really like that work horse Camillus) but except for the Camillus, these are all display knives and there's no excuse for sloppy workmanship.

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Wed Aug 10, 2011 8:34 pm
by jerryd6818
elbertson wrote:Phil - those knives of yours are nice! I really like the blade shape on that Bravo

Jerry - My guess on your Camillus is that it wasn't made for issue, mainly based on the handle not being coated with that Ox-blood brown or black coating, which would be spec. Other than that, I'm pretty sure there wouldn't be anything else about it that I can see that would be different than the issue ones. Markings would put it at 1974 or after.

Is your Ontario 440A?
I gotta tell you, that Kabar that came out of Marine Corps supply didn't have any kind of coating or finish applied to the handle. It was raw, almost white, fairly rough leather and I know for sure that was an issue knife. What I don't know is, what brand it was. I was 18 years old and used brand names like they were God's own truth so to me it was a Kabar no matter what was on the tang.

As far as the date on the Camillus, that's probably just about right. I kinda think I bought it in the late 70's but not positive.

Nothing in or on the box to say what kind of steel in the Ontario so sorry, I wouldn't have a clue. I don't know diddly about steels so I don't get involved with that. I'm a shallow man and just go for looks. :mrgreen:

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2011 11:50 pm
by rangerbluedog
Jerry, of all those, I like the first Camillus the best! ::tu:: <edit: cheez, I just noticed the steel pot in the background - too cool>
Got me to thinking about all the adventures I had carrying the issue Ontario I showed in the first post.
Carried that one for years. It had kind of gotten lost in my collection until recently. Brings back a lot of memories.
Just bought this little CRKT Sting today, along with a new sheath for my Ek Model 3. My reward to me for a hard week at work!
crktSting.jpg
I got the foliage green one
I got the foliage green one
I'm too good to me - but I deserve it! :lol:

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2011 4:54 pm
by philco
Careful there Blue. You'll work that arm out of socket doing all that back patting. ::tounge::

Nice additions to the pile.

Phil

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2011 5:39 pm
by elbertson
Blue, how's the retention on that sting sheath? Is there a kydex liner or something that holds it secure?

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2011 6:02 pm
by zed6309
wow guys these asre amazing, ive only one fixed blade knife a winchester, nothing in these legues but a nice knife and comfy,

Image

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2011 11:29 pm
by rangerbluedog
elbertson wrote:Blue, how's the retention on that sting sheath? Is there a kydex liner or something that holds it secure?
I'll let you know when it gets here. I took a bit of a chance on this one. There is a kydex "clip" on the sheath that fits into the spoon shaped divot on the handle.
If it comes back home with me after the first hike through the briars, I'll consider it acceptable. :mrgreen:

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 11:45 pm
by rangerbluedog
Turns out, the sheath is all kydex, with a cloth/nylon cover. It holds the knife very securely - better than I expected.

HOWEVER, I've decided this knife is just too small for my purposes. I think I'm gonna turn it around and try to trade it. Only 7" OAL - 3 1/2" blade :x bah!

Re: Some of my favorites

Posted: Thu Aug 25, 2011 10:18 pm
by justold52
This is the one that started me looking at more knives with the mans name of D'Holder on them.

Even on the Schrade the knife feels very well balanced. The drop point seems just right to me also.

Schrade D'Holder Burled Maple

Ken ???? will this ever stop wanting more????