GEC Stag
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
GEC Stag
GEC has used stag for handles right from the first runs of 73 & 23 patterns in 2006. Stag comes in a variety of colors and surface textures.
I do not have a lot of GEC stag handled knives but i will show a few in this post and hope that others will post some of their GEC stag so that we can see the full range that GEC has used.
A few years ago GEC tried to differentiate between "Natural Stag" and "Genuine Stag" and "Burnt Stag" and "Sambar Stag" and Sandbar Stag and maybe others, but it's all stag so let's see some.
Here are 4 examples: from top down: 561210 / 772215 / 351217 / 362209DP; all very nice stag.
Then there is the 141218. Notice how the white areas have been stained a fecal brown' color. I think this makes the entire piece of stag look bland and not attractive. I would like to hear how others see this new 'browned' stag.
kj
I do not have a lot of GEC stag handled knives but i will show a few in this post and hope that others will post some of their GEC stag so that we can see the full range that GEC has used.
A few years ago GEC tried to differentiate between "Natural Stag" and "Genuine Stag" and "Burnt Stag" and "Sambar Stag" and Sandbar Stag and maybe others, but it's all stag so let's see some.
Here are 4 examples: from top down: 561210 / 772215 / 351217 / 362209DP; all very nice stag.
Then there is the 141218. Notice how the white areas have been stained a fecal brown' color. I think this makes the entire piece of stag look bland and not attractive. I would like to hear how others see this new 'browned' stag.
kj
- gsmith7158
- Gold Tier
- Posts: 8548
- Joined: Fri Dec 25, 2015 7:25 pm
- Location: Canton, Ga. 100% of the time
- Contact:
Re: GEC Stag
Roland may I assume that Northwoods count here as well?
------------------
Greg
IF YOU AIN'T BUYING OR LOOKING AT A KNIFE THEN YOU AIN'T LIVING.
Always looking to buy good quality Empire knives.
PROUD MEMBER AAPK, NRA.
Greg
IF YOU AIN'T BUYING OR LOOKING AT A KNIFE THEN YOU AIN'T LIVING.
Always looking to buy good quality Empire knives.
PROUD MEMBER AAPK, NRA.
- Sharpnshinyknives
- Gold Tier
- Posts: 5104
- Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2018 2:32 am
- Location: Indiana
- Contact:
Re: GEC Stag
Roland, Seeing a line up of stag knives like that makes my heart race.
If a choice of natural stag and stained, I would vote for the natural stag. The stained doesn’t look quite right to me. I think it detracts from the appearance.
SSk
If a choice of natural stag and stained, I would vote for the natural stag. The stained doesn’t look quite right to me. I think it detracts from the appearance.
SSk
SSk Mark “Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same.” Ronald Reagan
- tongueriver
- Posts: 6834
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 8:01 pm
- Brumbydownunder
- Posts: 450
- Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2015 7:14 am
- Location: Central NSW Australia
Re: GEC Stag
Stage sure does 'lift' a knife to a new level ... some crackers here kj & Cal
A couple of mine (I think the #23 is technically Elk - but it's all 'stag' to me)
A couple of mine (I think the #23 is technically Elk - but it's all 'stag' to me)
"Belong Where The Moment Finds You"
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
Re: GEC Stag
Yes, Northwoods included, any knife made by GEC so we can get the full range of stag that GEC has used.
My impression is that recent GEC stag is not as attractive as the stag they used from the start up in 2006 to about 2017. (not exact date) i.e. at some point in last ~ 2-3 years the quality of stag has decreased.
The #14 i show in my opening post is a good example of what i mean by 'less attractive' stag.
I would like to know if others have on their own noted this decline in the stag quality.
Or, has there been some great stag in 2017 & 2018 that i just happened to miss ?
Is this all just going on in my head ? & everyone else sees the current stag as not that different from what was used previously ?
kj
My impression is that recent GEC stag is not as attractive as the stag they used from the start up in 2006 to about 2017. (not exact date) i.e. at some point in last ~ 2-3 years the quality of stag has decreased.
The #14 i show in my opening post is a good example of what i mean by 'less attractive' stag.
I would like to know if others have on their own noted this decline in the stag quality.
Or, has there been some great stag in 2017 & 2018 that i just happened to miss ?
Is this all just going on in my head ? & everyone else sees the current stag as not that different from what was used previously ?
kj
Re: GEC Stag
As individuals we can only offer anecdotal observations. I think the stag of 2018 which I purchased was from good to excellent. I am not a good photographer, coupled with work and a six year old leaves me taking pictures at niht. I like stag with texture from bolster to endcap or end of handle. I like flat fairly thin slabs, similar to bone thickness. I don't like thick or saddle like slabs. I don't like lots of material pilished off to fit the bolsters. By and large I got what I like this year.
On vacation right now but here's some older pics. 44 Gunstock. Excellent. Here is a mix of Northwoods. 2016/17 Bear Lake. Then 2018 Bear Lake and a pair of Fremonts followed by a 2017 Hawthorne.
The earlier Bear Lake is good, as is the second Fremont. The newer Bear Lake, first Fremont and the Hawthorne are exceptional.
On vacation right now but here's some older pics. 44 Gunstock. Excellent. Here is a mix of Northwoods. 2016/17 Bear Lake. Then 2018 Bear Lake and a pair of Fremonts followed by a 2017 Hawthorne.
The earlier Bear Lake is good, as is the second Fremont. The newer Bear Lake, first Fremont and the Hawthorne are exceptional.
Re: GEC Stag
43. Excellent and big. This one is going to look better with age.
Can't see, but perfect swell at the end of the handle. Here is a cache of doglegs old and new. 2010 genuine clip. Possibly my best hafted stag knife. Its neighbour is a 2018 and very similar in quality. Then a 2010 stag and another 2018. Again very similar. Not as good as the gems preceding, but good and then a nice 55 from 2013 in the natural stag.
Can't see, but perfect swell at the end of the handle. Here is a cache of doglegs old and new. 2010 genuine clip. Possibly my best hafted stag knife. Its neighbour is a 2018 and very similar in quality. Then a 2010 stag and another 2018. Again very similar. Not as good as the gems preceding, but good and then a nice 55 from 2013 in the natural stag.
Re: GEC Stag
The single blade in particular would have been easy to have put a shield on. But overall, I'd rather have texture and better stag than a shield.
That's most of my 2018 GEC stag. I think with the older comparison stags it shows consistent quality with what they've been doing all along. Not every single stag handled knife is going to be outstanding, but they are putting out a high percentage of examples which are very good to outstanding
- RalphAlsip
- Posts: 2320
- Joined: Sun Feb 02, 2014 9:01 pm
- Location: Southern Illinois
Re: GEC Stag
I'm staying up late waiting for Santa...
Roland, Cal, Brumby, and Rob, thank you for sharing your pictures. They are very nice examples.
Here is a collage of some stag handled knives that I believe were made by GEC. There are 3 GEC branded knives (35, 66, 16), 3 Northwoods (Fremont 79 & 2 Gladiators 54), and 2 Tuna Valley (4 blade cigar 54, large lock back trapper which I believe is a 23 pattern). Of the GEC branded knives, I like the 66 calf roper. It is apparent (to me) in my small sample size that the GEC SFO knives seem to get better handles.
I have the Northwoods large lock back trapper in stag, but it is a Queen Mountain Man pattern. It has nice stag, but I didn't include because not GEC made.
The enlarged image will be slow to download and display.
Roland, Cal, Brumby, and Rob, thank you for sharing your pictures. They are very nice examples.
Here is a collage of some stag handled knives that I believe were made by GEC. There are 3 GEC branded knives (35, 66, 16), 3 Northwoods (Fremont 79 & 2 Gladiators 54), and 2 Tuna Valley (4 blade cigar 54, large lock back trapper which I believe is a 23 pattern). Of the GEC branded knives, I like the 66 calf roper. It is apparent (to me) in my small sample size that the GEC SFO knives seem to get better handles.
I have the Northwoods large lock back trapper in stag, but it is a Queen Mountain Man pattern. It has nice stag, but I didn't include because not GEC made.
The enlarged image will be slow to download and display.
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
Re: GEC Stag
Thanks to you Prolific Posters this thread now shows a good range of GEC stag, range of time & texture. You guys have some very nice knives.
There are some recent examples of very nice stag so my impression of a decline in quality needs to be amended to: in the last about 2 years lesser quality stag is more common than previously.
At every stag release i go to various dealer sites to have a look. I have not been seeing the quality that Rob shows with his recent knives, so there is good stag but not much and it gets snapped up quickly.
The 141218 above which i will also post here, is a good example of what i mean by "lesser quality". I had a Calf Roper with similar dirty brown dyed stag but sold it because i was disappointed by the stag.
Do any of you have any similar GEC stag ? What do you think of it ? Why the brown dye ?
I'll just add that Rob's description above of what makes for a good stag handle, i agree with 100%.
kj
There are some recent examples of very nice stag so my impression of a decline in quality needs to be amended to: in the last about 2 years lesser quality stag is more common than previously.
At every stag release i go to various dealer sites to have a look. I have not been seeing the quality that Rob shows with his recent knives, so there is good stag but not much and it gets snapped up quickly.
The 141218 above which i will also post here, is a good example of what i mean by "lesser quality". I had a Calf Roper with similar dirty brown dyed stag but sold it because i was disappointed by the stag.
Do any of you have any similar GEC stag ? What do you think of it ? Why the brown dye ?
I'll just add that Rob's description above of what makes for a good stag handle, i agree with 100%.
kj
Re: GEC Stag
Roland, talking to Bill this year at the Rendezvous he stated that finding good stag is becoming an issue especially in larger sizes which is why the recent runs of large knives have been shorted. I do think the earlier knives have better stag although some of the 44's had exceptional stag.
Here are some of mine,
Here are some of mine,
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
Re: GEC Stag
JohnR, you have been able to select some excellent stag. The #73 from 2015 and the #85 Harness Jack from 2011 are about as good as stag gets.
I do not like the brown dye they are using on stag in the last 1-2 years.
kj
Edited by administrator for language.
REMINDER: We are a family site.
I do not like the brown dye they are using on stag in the last 1-2 years.
kj
Edited by administrator for language.
REMINDER: We are a family site.
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
Re: GEC Stag
Here are 2 'first run' knives from 2006. I think this stag #73 came from the first run of stag GEC did on this pattern. Same for the #23. Both have "2006" stamped into tang. This is very fine stag; i.e. the very first stag runs and they used the best stag.
I would buy another 2006 stag 73 or 23 because the stag is first rate and the knives are well made except some have overly strong springs.
Also showing a 23 from 2007 with "Red Stag". The "red" refers to the dye, not the European elk.
kj
I would buy another 2006 stag 73 or 23 because the stag is first rate and the knives are well made except some have overly strong springs.
Also showing a 23 from 2007 with "Red Stag". The "red" refers to the dye, not the European elk.
kj
Re: GEC Stag
Wow! Some beautiful knives being shown here.
David
"Glowing like the metal on the edge of a knife" Meat Loaf
"Glowing like the metal on the edge of a knife" Meat Loaf
Re: GEC Stag
kootenay joe wrote:JohnR, you have been able to select some excellent stag. The #73 from 2015 and the #85 Harness Jack from 2011 are about as good as stag gets.
I do not like the brown dye they are using on stag in the last 1-2 years.
kj
Edited by administrator for language.
REMINDER: We are a family site.
Roland, for what its worth I think your 14 is not dyed but natural Sanbar Stag, it can vary in color, I think GEC did a pretty good job on matching your scales and it is an attractive knife albeit different from the norm. As far as I know if GEC is going to dye, burn or polish stag they will market it as such.
I went through my collection and found knives from 17 and 18, most still have some pretty nice stag on them.
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
Re: GEC Stag
John, thanks for your post and your knives which show that GEC still mounts a lot of very good stag. These must be getting sold before i get to the dealer websites.
The 'dirty brown' color i don't like covers what normally would be the white that underlies the textured surface. I thought it was a dye job to make it look more like bolster to bolster stag.
If no dye is involved it is an unusual batch of antler: different species ? or old stock stored outside ? or ??
And, regarding "well matched", yes they are, but i do not require them to be. "Matching stag" is a relatively recent idea and i prefer the older idea of whatever the hafter felt would go nicely, sometimes a bit of a match, sometimes quite different. If it feels good in hand, then the handles are good.
kj
The 'dirty brown' color i don't like covers what normally would be the white that underlies the textured surface. I thought it was a dye job to make it look more like bolster to bolster stag.
If no dye is involved it is an unusual batch of antler: different species ? or old stock stored outside ? or ??
And, regarding "well matched", yes they are, but i do not require them to be. "Matching stag" is a relatively recent idea and i prefer the older idea of whatever the hafter felt would go nicely, sometimes a bit of a match, sometimes quite different. If it feels good in hand, then the handles are good.
kj
- Open Range-19
- Bronze Tier
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Wed May 30, 2018 3:24 pm
- Location: Western US
-
- Posts: 13373
- Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2016 5:36 pm
- Location: West Kootenays, B.C.
Re: GEC Stag
Very nice big jack you have O.R.
Are you making a long bow ?
kj
Are you making a long bow ?
kj
- Open Range-19
- Bronze Tier
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Wed May 30, 2018 3:24 pm
- Location: Western US
Re: GEC Stag
Thanks,
Grew up shooting hickory and osage bows made by a friend. I have not made a bow although used to make bowstrings & cedar arrows many years ago.
Grew up shooting hickory and osage bows made by a friend. I have not made a bow although used to make bowstrings & cedar arrows many years ago.