Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

In 1911, H. N. Platts, was able to draw on his extensive friendships and family connections in the cutlery world to start Western States Cutlery and Manufacturing of Boulder Colorado. At first only a jobbing business, by 1920 construction and machinery purchases were underway to begin manufacture of knives. Through name changes--to Western States Cutlery Co. in 1953, then Western Cutlery Co. in 1956--and moves first across town and later to Longmont Colorado, the company stayed under the leadership of the Platt family until 1984. In that year, the company was sold to Coleman, becoming Coleman-Western. Eventually purchased by Camillus in 1991, Western continued until Camillus expired in 2007.
Post Reply
User avatar
zzyzzogeton
Posts: 1722
Joined: Tue Jun 20, 2017 8:47 pm
Location: In the Heart of Texas on the Blackland Prairie

Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by zzyzzogeton »

When a Western knife has a colored handle and has ANY model number stamped on it other than P28, P48A or P48B,
IT HAS BEEN REHANDLED AND IS ABSOLUTELY NOT "factory mint", I don't care what the seller claims on fleabay.

The last KNOWN factory tenite handled knives were the 1960 catalog listings of the P48A and P28 B&Ts in red, ivory or yellow. These knives would have had

WESTERN
BOULDER, COLO,
MADE IN U.S.A.

on the mark side ricasso and

P48A or P28

on the pile side ricasso

If a Western knife has handles in colored Delrin of ANY color other than bone stag, it has been rehandled.

Also, if the color is one of the known tenite colors - red, ivory, yellow, orange, green (seafoam green pre-WW2 and dark green post-WW2) and possibly, very rarely, a dark blue and there is any pattern at all - swirl, "snakeskin", yellowjacket, etc, the knife has been rehandled.

If a Western knife has colored plastic/acrylic handles and also has a model number that begins with "L" or "F" or "6" or "W", it has been rehandled.

If a Western knife has colored handles and a model is stamped in the guard, it has been rehandled - the model numbers shifted to the guard in 1967 or 1968, depending on model and there were NO P-series knives being made by that time.

If a Western knife has colored handles and a date code as part of the stamp, it has been rehandled.

If a Western knife has colored handles and no mention of BOULDER, COLO. as part of the stamp, it has been rehandled. Any reference to BOULDER,COLO. was dropped in 1973, over a decade after the last factory colored handled knives left the shipping dock.

The 1966/1967 wholesaler's order sheet lists ZERO P-series, so definitely not made after 1965.

I have seen only 1 ad depicting a P-series type handled knife that was NOT a P48A, P48B, P28 (1955 to1960) or 48BGG, 48BAP 48CAP, 28AP (1947 to 1954) or 48/58/68BGH or 48/58/68BG (1941).

That was for a P39 in yellow tenite from sometime in the 1950s. I can't find my copy of the ad right now to narrow the year down any better than that right now.

There's multiple sources on fleabay for these rehandled Westerns. Most of the knives appear to very well assembled using real Western blades. The assemblers appear to do good work.

They just are NOT FACTORY ORIGINAL. They are NOT FACTORY MINT. They are NOT VINTAGE. They are not even "Factory Fresh", what ever the hell that means.

They are recently assembled knives using old blades that have been polished up. They are not, IMO, worth $$$$ to any real collector.

Will the knives work as knives? Maybe. Allegedly, these are being made from a Colorado source of leftover factory blades. Why were all these various era blades available to be "acquired for purchase from the factory" when it closed? Were they all seconds left hanging around in junk storage?

Will these knives ever perform a single cut of real work? Probably not.

Edited to correct grammar.
User avatar
Beavertail
Posts: 1195
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2008 9:47 pm
Location: Way down south in Dixie

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by Beavertail »

This is the kind of information people need so as to not get burned.
Thanks for the time and effort you put into this. ::tu:: ::handshake::
Tim
doglegg
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 17717
Joined: Mon Sep 18, 2017 2:35 am
Location: Grand Prairie, Texas

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by doglegg »

Z, thanks for the info. Very helpful. ::handshake::
ea42
Posts: 2963
Joined: Tue Oct 17, 2006 8:23 pm
Location: Wallkill, NY

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by ea42 »

Awesome info as usual Z, thank you!!! ::tu::

Eric
User avatar
btrwtr
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 5061
Joined: Thu May 24, 2012 11:53 am

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by btrwtr »

Great information Z.

I don't know what the buyers of these so many rehandled eBay Westerns are expecting or believing. That said I can't see any knowledgeable collector ever paying such prices.
If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of giants.

Wayne

Please visit My AAPK store https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/catalog/btrwtr
Felanmac
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jul 22, 2021 4:14 am
Location: Idaho

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by Felanmac »

Thank you again Zzyzz for this info!
A man without a knife is a man without a life
Thomasg
Posts: 494
Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2022 8:12 pm

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by Thomasg »

Would this be a good example of a western fixed blade that is a fake?
Attachments
0387C133-E615-4A91-B32A-01C798B176AB.png
User avatar
1967redrider
Gold Tier
Gold Tier
Posts: 16104
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2011 4:23 pm
Location: Alexandria, VA
Contact:

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by 1967redrider »

Near mint!!! ::facepalm:: I can't believe some defend this liar.
Pocket, fixed, machete, axe, it's all good!

You're going to look awfully silly with that knife sticking out of your @#$. -Clint Eastwood, High Plains Drifter
Thomasg
Posts: 494
Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2022 8:12 pm

Re: Western Color - What's factory and what's not?

Post by Thomasg »

zzyzzogeton wrote: Fri Dec 16, 2022 6:49 am When a Western knife has a colored handle and has ANY model number stamped on it other than P28, P48A or P48B,
IT HAS BEEN REHANDLED AND IS ABSOLUTELY NOT "factory mint", I don't care what the seller claims on fleabay.

The last KNOWN factory tenite handled knives were the 1960 catalog listings of the P48A and P28 B&Ts in red, ivory or yellow. These knives would have had

WESTERN
BOULDER, COLO,
MADE IN U.S.A.

on the mark side ricasso and

P48A or P28

on the pile side ricasso

If a Western knife has handles in colored Delrin of ANY color other than bone stag, it has been rehandled.

Also, if the color is one of the known tenite colors - red, ivory, yellow, orange, green (seafoam green pre-WW2 and dark green post-WW2) and possibly, very rarely, a dark blue and there is any pattern at all - swirl, "snakeskin", yellowjacket, etc, the knife has been rehandled.

If a Western knife has colored plastic/acrylic handles and also has a model number that begins with "L" or "F" or "6" or "W", it has been rehandled.

If a Western knife has colored handles and a model is stamped in the guard, it has been rehandled - the model numbers shifted to the guard in 1967 or 1968, depending on model and there were NO P-series knives being made by that time.

If a Western knife has colored handles and a date code as part of the stamp, it has been rehandled.

If a Western knife has colored handles and no mention of BOULDER, COLO. as part of the stamp, it has been rehandled. Any reference to BOULDER,COLO. was dropped in 1973, over a decade after the last factory colored handled knives left the shipping dock.

The 1966/1967 wholesaler's order sheet lists ZERO P-series, so definitely not made after 1965.

I have seen only 1 ad depicting a P-series type handled knife that was NOT a P48A, P48B, P28 (1955 to1960) or 48BGG, 48BAP 48CAP, 28AP (1947 to 1954) or 48/58/68BGH or 48/58/68BG (1941).

That was for a P39 in yellow tenite from sometime in the 1950s. I can't find my copy of the ad right now to narrow the year down any better than that right now.

There's multiple sources on fleabay for these rehandled Westerns. Most of the knives appear to very well assembled using real Western blades. The assemblers appear to do good work.

They just are NOT FACTORY ORIGINAL. They are NOT FACTORY MINT. They are NOT VINTAGE. They are not even "Factory Fresh", what ever the hell that means.

They are recently assembled knives using old blades that have been polished up. They are not, IMO, worth $$$$ to any real collector.

Will the knives work as knives? Maybe. Allegedly, these are being made from a Colorado source of leftover factory blades. Why were all these various era blades available to be "acquired for purchase from the factory" when it closed? Were they all seconds left hanging around in junk storage?

Will these knives ever perform a single cut of real work? Probably not.

Edited to correct grammar.
Here is a nice example of a fake with model # stamped on the guard .
IMG_2694.png
Attachments
IMG_2695.png
IMG_2692.png
IMG_2693.png
Post Reply

Return to “Western Cutlery Collector's Forum”