Here are the ones I have so far. (Next week I'll be getting the brown one arm and the lock back.) I've cleaned them up and oiled them and played a bit with them. Here are my thoughts.
Rough Ryder Reserve Swell Center Whittler D2 Black: $49.99 GRADE A-
Perfect- no flaws of any kind. It's a very large knife. Beautiful BIG main blade. The secondary blades are tiny in comparison. They let this one down a little. I kind of wish the coping blade was a bit larger, but it is OK as it is and that main blade is gorgeous. One design issue... The nail nicks on the coping and pen blades are partially obstructed by the swell center. I like the look of the knife, but the difference in size between the blades makes it look odd.
Rough Ryder Reserve Easy Open Sway Back Tan: $30.48 GRADE A+
Perfect- no flaws. Really nice blade. Gorgeous micarta. This one is a gem. I would really like a larger version of this. I've got a Case Sod Buster ordered. I'll be interested to compare it. This could be a useful work knife- even more so if it was a bit larger.
Rough Ryder Reserve Hedgehog D2 Black Micarta: $43.64 GRADE A+
Perfect- no flaws. VERY sweet knife. Not too big, not too small. This would be a perfect every day carry knife for me. This and the kayak are my favorites in this series so far.
Rough Ryder Reserve Common Stock D2 Black Micarta: $51.69 GRADE A+
Perfect- no flaws. My favorite large Stockman is the Buck 307. The Buck is a little more streamlined looking, but I actually like this one better than the Buck. Bigger main blade, half stop, nicer looking handles. I rarely use the spay blade on my Buck. The bottle opener will get more use when I'm out in the wild having a wild time.
Rough Ryder Reserve Kayak D2 Black Micarta: $75.00 (secondary market) GRADE A+
Perfect- no flaws. The natural color micarta is beautiful. It's more gray than tan. This is a very nice knife. Both blades are fantastic. My favorite medium/large knife from this series. I like it even better than the stockman.
I'll comment on the one arm and lock back when I get them.