Re: What Knife Would You Like GEC To Make ?
Posted: Tue Mar 12, 2019 8:11 pm
All About Pocket Knives is a knife related resource center for buying, selling, researching, and discussing all things knives
https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/knife_forum/
https://www.allaboutpocketknives.com/knife_forum/viewtopic.php?t=59808
kootenay joe wrote:Quote: "I just updated the message with the photos originally posted by Big Monk in 2011."
Stephen i am not seeing the pictures. Did you post them in this thread ?
kj
This link should take you directly to the post with the pictures - I hopeStephen wrote:
Jerry I too think the 29 will be an instant classic, but I am disappointed that no one has any expectations that there will be any sort of exotic handle material from GEC. What a shame. Are those days gone for good?RalphAlsip wrote:Piling on to comments about the #29 - of the patterns publicized for 2019 this is the one I am anticipating the most. My hopes for handles are yellow rose and a classic bone jig such as peach seed. Giraffe would be nice, but seems highly unlikely unless Northwoods is getting a SFO from this frame.
Here, here! I also intensely dislike the downward drooped, recurved blade on the 97. With its size it looks almost like a kukri. What happened to the straight clip blades of the 77? Is GEC ever going to do another run of 77s? If they care at all about sales, and want to do a large run, instead of these funny looking niche Coke bottles why not do a run of 77s for the Average Joe who just wants a "practical" (since it's in their logo!) pocketknife and not an oddity? Single clip and clip/pen 77s would sell and actually be appreciated by more people than the hardcore, "it's a traditional design from a page in history" type of buyer.Modern Slip Joints wrote:I want GEC to make a 97 large Coke bottle with an edge that is straight from its choil to the start of the curve up to its point. To avoid writing something negative in the 97 thread I've bit my toungue but it has to be said, GEC made what should have been a very traditional design in such a way that it can not be sharpened in the tradition way, on a flat rectangular stone. I wanted to like 97 Cokes and buy a few but I can't and won't. Recurved blades have no place in traditionals. With thousands of frames left to assemble is there hope GEC might offer some with good blades?
Like the #29 punch whittler!m0nk wrote:While I'm at it... Thankfully, the CK Early Reserve email said the #12 run would be a limited run, so hopefully it will be brief and short like the recent 99 run, and GEC can get back to making some decent pocket cutlery again.
What happened to buying a knife for sharp... cutting?kootenay joe wrote:The blade was designed for sharp looks.
The 97 is not a recurve. That kind of clip has been used on gec's for a long time but not all of them have it. Gec has used that blade on small stubby knives (like a 25 clip) and I do not like it on those but I think the 97 blade looks good. That's not to say it couldn't be better, which it could. The gec clip points like the 97 with the downwards angle and fairly abrupt curve to the point could be a more gradual curve that stretches the tip longer and into a more fine point. This looks better and is easier to sharpen.m0nk wrote:Here, here! I also intensely dislike the downward drooped, recurved blade on the 97. With its size it looks almost like a kukri. What happened to the straight clip blades of the 77? Is GEC ever going to do another run of 77s? If they care at all about sales, and want to do a large run, instead of these funny looking niche Coke bottles why not do a run of 77s for the Average Joe who just wants a "practical" (since it's in their logo!) pocketknife and not an oddity? Single clip and clip/pen 77s would sell and actually be appreciated by more people than the hardcore, "it's a traditional design from a page in history" type of buyer.Modern Slip Joints wrote:I want GEC to make a 97 large Coke bottle with an edge that is straight from its choil to the start of the curve up to its point. To avoid writing something negative in the 97 thread I've bit my toungue but it has to be said, GEC made what should have been a very traditional design in such a way that it can not be sharpened in the tradition way, on a flat rectangular stone. I wanted to like 97 Cokes and buy a few but I can't and won't. Recurved blades have no place in traditionals. With thousands of frames left to assemble is there hope GEC might offer some with good blades?
While I'm at it... Thankfully, the CK Early Reserve email said the #12 run would be a limited run, so hopefully it will be brief and short like the recent 99 run, and GEC can get back to making some decent pocket cutlery again.
- Lee
Hold a ruler to the edge of any of the 97 blades in the numerous pictures in threads and the curve will be obvious.KnifeSlinger#81 wrote: [...] The 97 is not a recurve. [...]
I think a #97 with an ornate swing gaurd would be a bit much, borderline gawdy. That said, with a blade this size, it would have been nice if at least some of them had been liner locks.Onearmbladejunkie wrote:I want GEC to make a #97 Allegheny knife with a swing-guard. Brass bolsters and a curvy style brass swing-guard ! A real old school knife. Oily Creek bone , autumn leaf bone , & tiger maple wood
Well I reckon I'm an oddity, but of the 47 GECs I currently have in my possession, I'd say 35-40 of them have recieved at least very light use. And every one has hung out in my pocket for at least a days time or two aside from one of the new Pembertons, a serialized Maverick I intend on selling/trading, and a rare, minty Ben Hogan I just cannot bring myself to blemish.kootenay joe wrote:What percentage of GEC knives sold to date have become users ? I bet less than 10%. Hence GEC's customers mostly want good looks as well as first rate workmanship. How easy/hard to sharpen the blade is not a consideration for the 90% who buy to collect.
kj
I'm gonna third that. The drop on the blade left me sitting on the sidelines, for this one.m0nk wrote:Here, here! I also intensely dislike the downward drooped, recurved blade on the 97. With its size it looks almost like a kukri. What happened to the straight clip blades of the 77? Is GEC ever going to do another run of 77s? If they care at all about sales, and want to do a large run, instead of these funny looking niche Coke bottles why not do a run of 77s for the Average Joe who just wants a "practical" (since it's in their logo!) pocketknife and not an oddity? Single clip and clip/pen 77s would sell and actually be appreciated by more people than the hardcore, "it's a traditional design from a page in history" type of buyer.Modern Slip Joints wrote:I want GEC to make a 97 large Coke bottle with an edge that is straight from its choil to the start of the curve up to its point. To avoid writing something negative in the 97 thread I've bit my toungue but it has to be said, GEC made what should have been a very traditional design in such a way that it can not be sharpened in the tradition way, on a flat rectangular stone. I wanted to like 97 Cokes and buy a few but I can't and won't. Recurved blades have no place in traditionals. With thousands of frames left to assemble is there hope GEC might offer some with good blades?
While I'm at it... Thankfully, the CK Early Reserve email said the #12 run would be a limited run, so hopefully it will be brief and short like the recent 99 run, and GEC can get back to making some decent pocket cutlery again.
- Lee
Nice one and well done with the mock up. A real useful pocket tool. Ebony and bar shield for a worker.RalphAlsip wrote:Paul, are you thinking something like this? This is a photoshop mock up. The nail nick on the sheepsfoot would probably be facing toward the back on a real knife.KnifeSlinger#81 wrote:I would LOVE to see a 35 cattle knife.
Three back springs for all full length blades or a whittler assembly? I'd buy at least one either way.Onearmbladejunkie wrote:I want a Great Eastern Cutlery 4 1/4" Gun-boat Canoe with a clip ,a spear , and a wharncliffe blade !